Blog > Employment Law

AI training and data annotation jobs: are you an employee or an independent contractor in California?

If you spend your days rating chatbot answers, writing prompts, labeling images, or checking an AI model’s math, you are part of a workforce many people never see. Many people do this work through online platforms, and many are told they’re independent contractors. In California, that label doesn’t always survive a close look. This guide is for anyone working AI training jobs: people paid to train, rate, or label data for AI systems who want to know what the law actually says they are.

AI training and data annotation jobs: are you an employee or an independent contractor in California?

Key Takeaways

  • The label isn’t the answer: for most jobs, California presumes people paid for work are employees unless the company proves all three parts of the ABC test.
  • Signs to look for: required onboarding, tracked task time, rates you can’t negotiate, quality scores that cut pay or access, and removal without notice.
  • Pay at stake: minimum wage for each hour worked, separate pay for required waiting time if you’re paid per task, overtime, and possibly equipment costs.
  • Clicked “I agree”? An arbitration clause can move your own claim out of court, but it generally can’t waive the representative part of a PAGA claim.
  • Act soon: platform access can end without warning, so save your records now. Wage claims generally reach back three years, or four in some cases, and a PAGA notice generally has a one-year deadline.

Updated

The work

1. What are AI training and data annotation jobs, and how do they pay?

They are the human side of building AI. People label data, write and grade prompts, rank chatbot answers, and flag harmful content. Some bring subject-matter knowledge, such as coding, law, or medicine, to teach a model what “good” looks like. The work usually comes through a platform. You apply, often pass an unpaid assessment, get placed on a project, and complete tasks inside the company’s software.

Pay usually comes one of three ways. Per task, a set amount per unit regardless of time. Per hour, where the platform tracks your active time and pays a rate that can change from project to project. Or per project, with a lump sum for a defined batch of work. Many platforms issue a 1099 and call the worker a contractor. Our guide to 1099 vs. W-2 in California explains why that form doesn’t settle the question.

Employee or contractor

2. Are AI trainers employees or independent contractors in California?

Under California law, many may be employees, whatever the platform calls them. California uses the ABC test. It starts by presuming that anyone who does work for pay is an employee. The company can only treat you as a contractor if it proves all three of the following: (A) you’re free from its control over how you do the work; (B) the work you do is outside the company’s usual business; and (C) you’re actually running your own independent business doing that kind of work for others. Fail any one and you’re generally an employee.

Apply that to a data platform. Prong A is hard to meet for a company that assigns projects, sets detailed guidelines, scores your quality, times your tasks, and removes you when your numbers slip. Prong B may be harder still for a company whose business is supplying labeled data, because the annotators’ work is what it sells. Prong C asks whether you have your own independent annotation business, with your own clients. Some occupations are exempt from the ABC test, and companies sometimes argue those exemptions apply. The facts of your day decide it, and a legal professional can walk through them with you.

Warning signs

3. What signs suggest you may be misclassified?

The more the platform runs your workday, the more likely you’re an employee. Look for these:

  • You had to complete the company’s training, onboarding, or certification before you could earn anything.
  • Your active time is tracked by the software, with idle time clipped and task timers enforced.
  • The company sets the pay rate for each project, and you can’t negotiate it or bill your own rate.
  • Your work is graded against the company’s rubric, and a low quality score or “audit” cuts your pay or your access.
  • You can be removed from a project, or the platform, without notice.
  • Detailed guidelines tell you exactly how to write, rate, or label, and reviewers correct you when you deviate.
  • You do this work for one platform, not a roster of your own clients.
  • The company’s whole business is the work you’re doing.

None of these alone decides the question, but the more you can check, the stronger the sign that the platform is acting like an employer. A free case review can look at whether your platform classified you correctly.

Missing pay

4. What pay could you be missing?

If you’re an employee under the ABC test, the time you spent working for the platform was generally supposed to be paid, not just the minutes the software counted. A test you take just to get onto a platform may not count as paid time. Required training, onboarding, and qualification exams after you’re accepted generally do. Time you spent waiting for a task to load, reading guidelines, or redoing work after a reviewer’s correction generally counts too.

California requires at least the minimum wage, $16.90 an hour in 2026 and $17.40 from January 1, 2027, for each hour worked. If you’re paid by the hour, an employer can’t average a good hour against a bad one. If you’re paid per task, a task that paid $8 but took an hour may still fall short. If you’re paid per task, time under the company’s control that isn’t part of the paid task, such as waiting or required reading, generally has to be paid separately (Labor Code section 226.2). Days over eight hours and weeks over 40 generally earn overtime at time and a half. And the costs of a laptop, internet service, or software the work required may be expenses the employer owes you back.

We cover how unpaid minutes add up in our article on working off the clock, and what the company may owe for your equipment in our article on work expense reimbursement. A free case review can put a number on all of it.

The lawsuits

5. What are the lawsuits against Scale AI, DataAnnotation, and other AI data companies about?

Mostly the same claim: that people doing AI training work were employees paid like contractors. These are allegations, and the companies can contest them.

In December 2024, former contributors sued Scale AI and its affiliate Smart Ecosystem, which does business as Outlier, in San Francisco Superior Court. They claimed they were misclassified as independent contractors and not paid minimum wage, overtime, and other wages owed. The defendants strongly deny violating any laws but agreed to a $12.5 million class settlement for contributors who lived in California, including $500,000 in PAGA penalties. The court granted final approval on October 30, 2026.

In May 2025, a data annotator sued Surge Labs, which does business as DataAnnotation, in the same court. The complaint alleges unpaid assessments and qualification exams, time limits that left some work unpaid, missed meal and rest breaks, and unreimbursed costs for phones, computers, and internet service. In September 2026, Bloomberg Law reported that at least five misclassification suits by AI trainers were pending in California. If your experience sounds like these complaints, a legal professional can tell you whether your platform is already in litigation, or whether a settlement may already cover your claims.

Arbitration clauses

6. Does it matter if you clicked “I agree” to arbitration?

It can matter a lot, but it isn’t always the last word. Many platform sign-ups include an arbitration clause and a class action waiver in the terms of service. Outlier’s terms, for example, say disputes “will be resolved only in individual arbitration.” A valid clause can push your own claim into private arbitration instead of court, and a valid class waiver can keep you out of a class action. It generally can’t waive the representative part of a PAGA claim, the part brought on behalf of the state and your coworkers. A court may pause that part while the arbitration goes forward, and if the arbitrator decides you weren’t an employee, that finding can end the PAGA claim too. And a clause that is one-sided, hidden, or never actually agreed to may not hold up at all. Our article on arbitration agreements at work explains the exceptions. Before assuming a click-through closed the door, have a legal professional read what you clicked.

First steps

7. What should you do if you think you’re misclassified?

Start by saving everything the platform lets you see, because access can disappear overnight. Export or screenshot your task history, time logs, quality scores, and pay statements. Keep copies of your own onboarding records and any assessment you completed without pay. If you signed a confidentiality agreement, ask a lawyer before copying project guidelines or any client data. Save emails, chat messages, and support tickets. Log the hours you actually spent, including waiting and training.

Then watch the deadlines. Unpaid wage and expense claims generally reach back three years, or four in some cases, and a PAGA notice generally has to be filed within one year of the violations you personally experienced. Our guide to California employment deadlines has the details. A free case review can sort out what you have and what it’s worth.

Talk to a California employment lawyer

Training AI for a platform that calls you a contractor?

The people training AI deserve the same protections as everyone else who works in California. If a platform has called you a contractor while running your workday, the California employment lawyers at Wilshire Law Firm offer a free case review, available 24/7, with no fees unless you get paid. You can also start your case review online. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Share this page

Send it to someone who could use it, or copy it into ChatGPT, Gemini or your notes.

Related Content

Guides, nearby offices, and related practice areas.

Start Your Free Case Review

4.9 stars from 2,520 reviews
  • Available 24/7
  • Hablamos Español
  • Nationally-Recognized Powerhouse Team
As seen in:

We'll contact you within minutes

No fees unless you get paid.

By submitting this form, you knowingly, voluntarily, and expressly consent to receive from Wilshire Law Firm telephone calls, emails, and SMS text messages, including those made using an automatic telephone dialing system (auto-dialer), artificial intelligence (AI), and/or pre-recorded or artificial voice messages. These communications are for the purpose of providing prompt consultation regarding your potential case. You understand that by providing your telephone number, you are granting permission to be contacted for this purpose, even if your number is on a federal or state Do-Not-Call registry. Consent is not required as a condition of retaining Wilshire Law Firm. Message and data rates may apply. You may revoke your consent to receive calls, texts, or emails at any time by replying “STOP” to any text message, calling 888-557-3271, filling out the form at wilshirelawfirm.com/do-not-contact or by any other reasonable method. For more information, refer to our Privacy Policy.

Locations

Find your nearest office — serving all of California and employment clients in Oregon and Washington.

Appointments required for office visitsCall 213-754-1375 to schedulePrefer to start online? Start my free case review