Sexual Abuse
Blog > Sexual Abuse
Alameda County Jury Awards $14.3 Million in Diocese of Oakland Clergy Abuse Trial
An Alameda County jury awarded $14.3 million on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, in a lawsuit alleging that a former priest of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland sexually abused the plaintiff as a child in 1976, Bay Area News Group reported. It was the second of six bellwether trials.

The $14.3 Million Diocese of Oakland Verdict
What the Alameda County jury decided on November 17
The jury returned its verdict against the Diocese of Oakland in Alameda County Superior Court after a day of deliberations, according to Bay Area News Group and EWTN News. The survivor who brought the case was abused as a child in 1976 after a group outing with the priest, the survivor’s attorney said, according to Bay Area News Group.
It was the second eight-figure verdict against the diocese this year. In April, a jury awarded $16 million to a different survivor who alleged abuse by the same former priest in 1975, bringing the total the diocese has been ordered to pay in the two trials to $30.3 million, Bay Area News Group reported.
The two cases are the first of six so-called bellwether trials. They were allowed to move toward trial after years of delays and slow settlement talks between the diocese and the roughly 350 people who have sued it over abuse dating back decades, according to Bay Area News Group.
What the Diocese of Oakland Has Said
A statement on the verdict and the bankruptcy case
In a statement Tuesday evening, a diocese spokesperson said, “While acknowledging the jury’s verdict, the Oakland Diocese is committed to providing fair and just compensation to all victims/survivors, and continues to work towards that goal in the bankruptcy process,” Bay Area News Group reported. The diocese gave EWTN News a similar statement on November 18.
The diocese filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in 2023, after a state law that temporarily lifted the time limit on these claims led to a wave of lawsuits, and the filing effectively put those cases on hold, Bay Area News Group reported. In October, a federal bankruptcy judge rejected the diocese’s plan to resolve the bankruptcy, according to both outlets, and the survivor’s attorney said a new mediator has since been brought in.
One recent diocese proposal called for $172.3 million for survivors, including $30 million from a related corporation that oversees the diocese’s schools, while one survivors’ court filing earlier this year sought $314.1 million, Bay Area News Group reported. We may update this article as the bankruptcy and the remaining trials move forward.
What Happens After the Oakland Diocese Verdict
Why a jury award is not yet a payment
A verdict can still be challenged. The party that lost may ask the trial judge to set the verdict aside and enter judgment in its favor, or to order a new trial, and a final judgment can generally be taken to the Court of Appeal (Code of Civil Procedure §§629, 657, 904.1). Neither report said whether the diocese plans to do any of that.
Payment raises a second question. Because the diocese remains in Chapter 11, when and how this award is paid may depend on the bankruptcy case, where the diocese says it is working toward compensation for survivors.
Clergy Abuse Survivors’ Rights in California
Time limits for childhood abuse claims
California sets no time limit for a civil case over childhood sexual abuse that happened on or after January 1, 2024 (Code of Civil Procedure §340.1). For abuse before that date, a case generally has to be filed by the survivor’s 40th birthday or within five years after the survivor discovers, as an adult, that a psychological injury was caused by the abuse, whichever comes later. SB 577 cuts that five-year discovery period to three years starting January 1, 2027 (Code of Civil Procedure §340.11).
These claims can be brought against the person who committed the abuse and against an organization, such as a church or diocese, whose wrongful or negligent acts helped cause it. The lawsuits against the Diocese of Oakland have been largely on hold during its bankruptcy, so that case shapes how those claims move forward. Our page on abuse at churches and other institutions explains more.
This is a general summary of California law, not legal advice; the dates and facts of each survivor’s situation decide which rules apply.
East Bay Clergy Abuse Help From Wilshire Law Firm
Confidential consultations for survivors, available 24/7
Wilshire Law Firm represents survivors of childhood sexual abuse in claims against churches, schools, and other institutions across California. Our sexual abuse lawyers meet with East Bay survivors at our Oakland office, home to the firm’s Oakland personal injury team.
A legal professional can listen in confidence, explain the options that may fit your situation, and deal with the institution and its insurers so you don’t have to. Meet our legal team, or read our coverage of an athletic trainer’s arrest at a Catholic high school in San Jose, a lawsuit over a former Contra Costa County juvenile hall clinician, and a $29 million jury verdict against ABC Unified.
If a child is in immediate danger, call 911. Suspected abuse can also be reported to local law enforcement or the county’s child welfare agency.
Talk to Wilshire Law Firm
Were you harmed by abuse at a church or religious school?
It can take years before a survivor is ready to talk about abuse by someone in a position of trust. When you are, a Wilshire Law Firm legal professional can hear what happened in confidence and explain your options, at no cost and with no pressure. There are no fees unless you get paid.
FAQs
$14.3 million, in a verdict returned on November 17, 2026, in Alameda County Superior Court, according to Bay Area News Group and EWTN News. A different jury awarded $16 million against the diocese in April, so the two bellwether verdicts total $30.3 million.
Not necessarily. The verdict can still face post-trial motions or an appeal, and because the Diocese of Oakland is in Chapter 11 bankruptcy, the timing and amount of any payment may depend on that case. The diocese said it is working toward compensation for survivors in the bankruptcy process.
It can be. California law allows a childhood sexual abuse claim against a person or organization that owed the survivor a duty of care when its wrongful or negligent act was a legal cause of the abuse (Code of Civil Procedure §340.1). Whether a church or diocese is responsible depends on what it knew and how it responded.
For abuse before 2024, the general deadline is the survivor’s 40th birthday, or five years after discovering, as an adult, that the abuse caused a psychological injury, if that is later. That five-year period becomes three years on January 1, 2027, under SB 577 (Code of Civil Procedure §340.11). Abuse on or after January 1, 2024, has no deadline.
Nothing up front. Wilshire Law Firm works on contingency, so there are no fees unless you get paid. Case reviews are free and available 24/7.
Send it to someone who could use it, or copy it into ChatGPT, Gemini or your notes.
Related Content
Guides, nearby offices, and related practice areas.
