Class Action
Blog > Class Action
Greenwashing on packaging: what “recyclable,” “biodegradable,” and “eco-friendly” really mean
You may have paid a little more for trash bags marked “compostable,” a bottle with the recycling arrows, or sunscreen labeled “reef safe.” But was the claim true? Greenwashing on packaging is a green claim on a product’s label that is false or exaggerated. This guide is for shoppers who paid for a claim like that. It explains what common label words mean under federal guidance that applies nationwide, and where California adds stricter rules.

Key Takeaways
- What it is: greenwashing on packaging is a green word, symbol, or image on a label that’s false or exaggerated.
- “Recyclable”: federal guidance allows the plain claim only where recycling is available to at least 60 percent of buyers. A July 2026 court order bars California’s Attorney General from enforcing the state’s stricter SB 343 rule.
- “Biodegradable” vs. “compostable”: biodegradable means the whole item fully breaks down soon after disposal; compostable means it turns into usable compost. California bars “biodegradable” labels, with narrow exceptions.
- Vague words: “eco-friendly” needs a specific, explained benefit, and California requires website disclosures behind “carbon neutral” claims.
- Proof matters: in California, a shopper must show a claim is false or misleading, not just unproven. Keep the package or photos of it, and your receipt if you have one.
Defining greenwashing
1. What is greenwashing on product packaging?
Greenwashing is making a product look better for the environment than it is. On packaging, it can be a word (“eco-friendly”), a symbol (the recycling arrows), or an image (leaves, a globe, a forest). The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) publishes the Green Guides, which explain how the agency views these claims. They cover claims about a product or its package, whether stated outright or implied.
The core rule is simple. Every reasonable reading of a green claim must be true, not misleading, and backed by a reasonable basis before it goes on the package. A claim can also mislead by overstating a benefit, such as calling a package “greener” when the only change is a minor one.
Label examples
2. What are common examples of greenwashing on a label?
These claim types show up on everyday products. Each can be fine when it’s true and explained. Each can mislead when it isn’t.
- Bags and food containers stamped “biodegradable” that are likely to end up in a landfill, where the FTC treats an unqualified claim like that as deceptive.
- Wipes sold as “plant-based,” with nature images on the package, that contain synthetic ingredients.
- Bottles and tubs with the recycling arrows when the cap, label, or shape keeps them from being recycled, or when few local programs accept them.
- Sunscreen labeled “reef safe” or “free of” one chemical, when it contains other ingredients that the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration lists among sunscreen chemicals that can harm marine life.
- Packaging with a broad “eco-friendly,” “green,” or “earth-friendly” banner and nothing saying what makes it so.
- A “made with plant-based materials” claim when only part of the package is.
Under the Green Guides, even a truthful “free of” claim can mislead if the product contains other substances with the same or similar environmental risks.
Recycling symbols
3. What do “recyclable” and the recycling symbol mean?
Under the Green Guides, “recyclable” means the item can be collected, separated, or recovered through an established recycling program to make something new. A label can say it without qualification only if recycling facilities are available to at least 60 percent of the consumers or communities where it’s sold. Below that, it should say something like “may not be recyclable in your area,” and with much less access, it should say more plainly how few places accept it. The small number inside a triangle of arrows is a resin identification code. Under the Green Guides, a code tucked on the bottom isn’t a recyclable claim on its own.
California goes further. A 2021 state law, SB 343 (Public Resources Code section 42355.51), treats the arrows or the word “recyclable” as deceptive unless the item meets statewide recyclability criteria. CalRecycle says the rule covers products made after October 4, 2026. But on July 14, 2026, a federal court issued a preliminary injunction barring California’s Attorney General, and anyone acting with him, from enforcing SB 343 until further order. The order is preliminary, and the federal guidance still applies.
Two different promises
4. What is the difference between “biodegradable” and “compostable”?
“Biodegradable” is a broad promise: the whole item will completely break down and return to nature within a reasonably short time after normal disposal. The FTC says a plain “biodegradable” claim is deceptive for trash that won’t completely decompose within a year, which includes items headed to a landfill, an incinerator, or a recycling facility.
“Compostable” is narrower: every material in the item will turn into usable compost, safely and in about the same time as the rest of the pile. If it needs an industrial facility rather than a backyard bin, the label should say so. It should also say so when those facilities aren’t available to a substantial majority of shoppers where it’s sold.
California is stricter: it bars selling a product labeled “biodegradable,” “degradable,” or “decomposable,” with narrow exceptions (Public Resources Code section 42357). A green, beige, or brown tint on a plastic shopping or produce bag that doesn’t qualify as compostable can count as implying it will break down. A “compostable” label must meet a recognized scientific standard and other state rules.
Vague green words
5. What about “eco-friendly,” “plant-based,” and “carbon neutral”?
“Eco-friendly” and “green” are general environmental benefit claims. The FTC says they’re hard to interpret and hard to prove, so a label shouldn’t use them without a clear qualifier naming the specific benefit.
“Plant-based” can be read as a renewable-materials claim, which the FTC says should generally be qualified by naming the material and why it’s renewable, unless the whole item is made from it. In 2024, a federal appeals court held that a front label calling baby wipes “plant-based,” with nature images and no qualifier, could plausibly lead shoppers to think they had no synthetic ingredients.
“Carbon neutral” often rests on carbon offsets, which the FTC says need reliable scientific and accounting methods. Since 2024, a business making that claim in California must post online how it determined the claim is accurate and whether it’s independently verified (Health and Safety Code section 44475.2).
What the law says
6. Is it legal to put a misleading green claim on a package?
No. Federal law makes deceptive acts in commerce unlawful, and the FTC enforces it (15 U.S.C. section 45). The Green Guides are guidance, not binding rules: they don’t create rights for shoppers, but the FTC can act against claims that don’t square with them. Your state’s consumer protection laws may also apply.
If you live in California, Business and Professions Code section 17580.5 makes an untruthful, deceptive, or misleading environmental marketing claim unlawful, and it covers the claims in the Green Guides. A company that follows the Guides generally has a defense under that section, but not against claims under California’s recycling-symbol and resin-code rules. A misleading label can also violate the Unfair Competition Law, the False Advertising Law, and the Consumers Legal Remedies Act. Our article on false advertising claims explains those laws.
There’s a limit in California: a shopper must prove the label is false or misleading. A California appeals court held in 2003, and a federal appeals court agreed in 2017, that private plaintiffs can’t make a company prove its claims. A label that simply lacks support may not be enough.
Your options
7. What can you do if you paid more for a claim that wasn’t true?
You may be able to act alone or as part of a group. For a single purchase, small claims court may be an option. Limits vary by state; in California, an individual can generally claim up to $12,500.
When the same label reached many buyers, a class action may make more sense. In California, a person who lost money or property because of a misleading claim can bring a claim under the Unfair Competition Law. Before seeking damages under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act, a shopper must send the company a written notice and a request to fix the problem. It goes by certified or registered mail at least 30 days ahead (Civil Code section 1782). Time limits generally run three years under that act and four under the Unfair Competition Law.
Wilshire Law Firm is headquartered in California and handles consumer protection class actions nationwide.
Evidence to keep
8. What should you keep?
The label is the evidence, so hold on to it if you can:
- The package itself, or clear photos of the front label and every side, including symbols and fine print.
- Your receipt, order confirmation, or card statement, if you have one. It’s helpful, but you may not need it.
- The price you paid and, if you can, the price of a similar product without the green claim.
- A note of where and when you bought it, and why the claim mattered to you.
Photos of the front label can matter a lot, since that’s what a shopper sees first.
Talk to a consumer class action lawyer
Paid extra for a green claim that didn’t hold up?
A green label is a promise you paid for. If you think it wasn’t true, the consumer class action attorneys at Wilshire Law Firm offer a free case review, available 24/7, with no fees unless you get paid. You can also start your case review online. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Send it to someone who could use it, or copy it into ChatGPT, Gemini or your notes.
Related Content
Guides, nearby offices, and related practice areas.
Pedestrian & Bicycle Accidents
